Breaking the Stigma: How Pastors Can Lead the Church in Mental Health Ministry

For many pastors, conversations about mental health ministry still feel uncharted and even uncomfortable. Yet depression, anxiety, and loneliness don’t stay outside the church doors—they live in our pews, our homes, and often within our own lives as leaders.
If the church is called to be a refuge for the weary (Matthew 11:28), we cannot shy away from the reality of mental health struggles. Pastors and church leaders have a unique opportunity to break the stigma, foster compassion, and create communities where burdens are shared openly instead of carried in silence.
Why Mental Health Matters for Pastors and Churches
- 1 in 5 U.S. adults live with a mental illness (National Institute of Mental Health, 2023).
- 31% of U.S. adults report feeling lonely “frequently or almost all of the time” (CDC, 2023).
- According to Barna Group, 42% of pastors say they have considered quitting full-time ministry in the past year, citing stress and isolation as leading reasons.
These numbers are not “out there”—they are in our churches, and often in the pulpit. Breaking stigma around mental health is not just compassionate; it’s essential pastoral care.
What Stigma Looks Like in Ministry
Stigma often takes the form of subtle messages. Here are some examples pastors can reflect on:
Harmful phrases
- “If you just prayed harder, this would go away.”
- “Depression is just a lack of faith.”
- “Real Christians shouldn’t struggle with anxiety.”
Helpful alternatives
- “Even Elijah, David, and Paul experienced seasons of deep anguish.”
- “God meets us in our weakness and carries us through it.”
- “You are not alone, and help is available.”
By shifting language, we move from shame to support.
Practical Ways Pastors Can Break the Stigma
- Normalize the Conversation
- Preach sermons that reference mental health honestly and biblically.
- Share statistics to remind congregants they are not alone.
- Equip Your Leaders
- Train staff and lay leaders in mental health ministry basics.
- Point to resources like NIMH, Sanctuary Mental Health Ministries, or Grace Alliance.
- Model Vulnerability
- Share your own struggles wisely, demonstrating that Christian leaders and mental health can coexist faithfully.
- Remind caregivers and families in your congregation that their role matters deeply—and they too need support.
Caregiver Support: Don’t Forget the Families
When someone is struggling with depression or anxiety, their spouse, parents, or children often carry unseen burdens. Pastors can:
- Offer respite through meals, childcare, or prayer support.
- Create caregiver support groups where experiences can be shared without judgment.
- Acknowledge caregivers in prayers and teaching, affirming their faithfulness.
Join the Movement: Thrive & Cultivate Loneliness Summit
Breaking stigma is not a solo mission—it requires equipping, encouragement, and community. That’s why the Thrive & Cultivate Loneliness Summit exists.
This virtual event brings together pastors, church leaders, and mental health experts to tackle loneliness, anxiety, and depression with biblical wisdom and practical strategies.
Register today to save your spot and learn how to create churches where no one suffers in silence.
FAQ’s
Why is mental health important in ministry?
Because pastors care for the whole person—body, mind, and spirit. Addressing mental health is part of shepherding well.
How can pastors talk about depression without making it seem unspiritual?
By grounding conversations in Scripture (like Elijah’s despair in 1 Kings 19 or David’s laments in Psalms) and reminding people that God meets us in our weakness.
What resources are available for churches starting mental health ministries?
Start with trusted organizations like Sanctuary Mental Health Ministries, Grace Alliance, and Barna’s research on pastors and mental health.
Final Reflection
As pastors and Christian leaders, we are entrusted with souls that often carry hidden pain. Breaking the stigma of mental health in the church is not just about awareness—it is about embodying the compassion of Christ, who drew near to the brokenhearted (Psalm 34:18).
May your ministry be a place where no one suffers alone, where caregivers are supported, and where the hope of Christ shines through even the darkest valleys.
Don’t miss this opportunity—register now for the Loneliness Summit and join other leaders committed to breaking stigma and building healthier communities.
Become AĀ Thrive & Cultivate All-AccessĀ Member Today
Don't stop learning about mental health. Watch all of theĀ workshopsĀ from this year's summit and from previous Thrive & Cultivate summits when you become a member. Plus, you'll access to resources like a team training calendar, digital magazines, mental health FAQ videos, and more!